Beauty Pie Reviews

Beauty Pie has an overall rating of 4.6 based on 24 reviews. Customer feedback on Beauty Pie is mixed: Beauty Pie reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality products at affordable prices, transparent pricing model, wide range of skincare and makeup options, excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to beauty enthusiasts looking for quality and value. However, Beauty Pie is often criticized for its membership fee required, limited availability of some products, shipping delays reported, some products may not suit all skin types.

4.6/5.0

24 reviews

5 Stars

15

4 Stars

2

3 Stars

1

2 Stars

2

1 Star

0

All Beauty Pie Reviews (24)
Thomas_reed70
April 30, 2026
"My sensitive skin is actually happy"
I have super sensitive skin, and usually new products make me red, itchy, or both. I tried a few Beauty Pie things expecting the usual drama, but so far I’ve had zero bad reactions. My skin feels calm and really soft, which surprised me. I blame whoever runs this because now I’m tempted to try even more.
crystal-Warren
April 30, 2026
"Good value if you order enough, I think?"
I’ve found beautypie can be good value, especially if you’re ordering a few things at the same time. Some of the products feel really nice for the price, particularly the skincare, and it’s nice being able to try things without paying those crazy in-store prices, you know? That said, once you add in the membership and delivery, it doesn’t always feel quite as cheap as it first seems. A couple of items I tried were just okay for me — not bad, but not amazing either. I’d probably order again, but only when I actually need enough stuff to make it feel worth it, if that makes sense?
claude1984
April 23, 2026
"Easy cancellation, even though I left it late"
I needed to cancel quickly, i was expecting a hassle because I’d left it a bit last minute — that was on me. But it was sorted fast with no drama, which I really appreciated.
MOORE
April 12, 2026
"Glad I ended up joining"
I wasn’t totally sure about paying for a membership at first, but it’s been worth it. Once you’re in, the prices are way better, and I’ve already found a few skincare and makeup products I keep going back for. It’s nice not feeling like I’m getting hit with crazy markups every time I need something. Delivery’s been totally fine too. Overall, I’m happy I signed up.
gladyscarlson4912
April 10, 2026
"Stayed on way better than I expected"
I tried the foundation and the mascara, and both held up all day. I kept checking my face randomly, especially the foundation, and it didn’t go patchy or weird. The mascara was good too, like it barely smudged, which is usually a problem for me. Also just really liked how everything looked overall. Super happy with it.
charles.Lewis
March 19, 2026
"Arrived in great shape"
My order showed up packed really well, and nothing leaked or got damaged. Even my sister noticed the boxes looked neat without being overdone. Overall, I’m really happy with how everything arrived.
marcelino_Goldson05
March 18, 2026
"Actually Feels Good on My Skin"
Okay, not to be dramatic, but why is it so hard to find something that actually feels nice on your skin? This one does. It goes on smoothly, doesn’t feel gross or sticky, and my skin just feels comfortable after using it. that alone is enough for me.
James_auger76
March 13, 2026
"I had a small issue with…"
I had a small issue with my order and messaged Beauty Pie while I was feeling a bit annoyed and not really expecting a quick reply. To my surprise, they got back to me the same day. The person I spoke to was friendly and sorted everything out without making it feel like a hassle. I really appreciated how easy the whole thing was, and it definitely makes me feel better about ordering again...
hello_judith974
February 11, 2026
"Exactly as Described!"
Everything was just like the description said — no weird surprises or anything 🙂 Really happy with it!
MadonnaCassidy
January 30, 2026
"Reliable deliveries every time"
I’ve ordered from Beauty Pie a few times now and it’s been really straightforward. The parcels show up when they’re supposed to, everything’s packed properly, and I’ve never had to chase anything. Their updates are basically like, “your order’s on the way” and then it just turns up, which is all I want.
hello_kathleen383
January 30, 2026
"Return was easy and the refund came fast"
I had to send back a couple of Beauty Pie items because one of the shades just didn’t work for me, which is always a bit annoying, but anyway I was expecting the return to be more of a pain than it was.
I filled in the return details, posted everything back, and I kept getting updates without needing to chase anyone. Also, I had one small question and customer service got back to me really quickly, so that was a nice surprise.

The refund came through faster than I thought it would too. Overall it was handled really smoothly, and it makes me feel much more comfortable ordering again, even if I’m not totally sure about a shade next time
Tracy_scott77
January 25, 2026
"The whole experience was kind of frustrating. The…"
The whole experience was kind of frustrating. The pages took forever to load, and checkout was more confusing than it needed to be. On top of that, the reminders felt really aggressive, like they kept pushing me to finish before I was ready. Not a great experience overall.
Perry_stone86
January 21, 2026
"Usually Has What I Need"
Beautypie usually has the things I’m looking for in stock, which is really nice because I don’t have to keep checking back over and over, and it makes it super easy to just grab my usual products when I need them
hello_tammy370
January 20, 2026
"Fast Results and Calmer Skin"
I was surprised by how quickly it worked. After using it, my skin felt noticeably calmer and less irritated. From my experience, it’s definitely been a soothing addition to my routine
minnie_Deleone94
January 12, 2026
"Really impressed for the price"
I was in a relaxed, treat-myself kind of mood when I tried these, i was surprised by how good they smelled. They don’t have that cheap, sharp scent that some perfumes do, and they actually lasted well on me. I even got a few compliments, which was a nice bonus. For the price, I’m really happy with them and would definitely buy again.
jade.Harper
January 04, 2026
"I finally found my shade easily, which…"
I finally found my shade easily, which was kind of a relief. It matched way better than I expected and didn’t take forever to figure out
lorileslie8493
January 01, 2026
"Quick delivery that felt oddly reassuring"
I ordered from Beauty Pie on a Monday and my parcel was already with me by Wednesday, which surprised me in the best way. Everything was packed properly, and the tracking kept updating, so I wasn’t left wondering where my order had disappeared to. I’ve had slower deliveries from stores much closer to me, so this one stood out. It’s a small thing, but when a company gets the basics right, it makes the whole shopping experience feel a lot more dependable.
Phyllis_kulish73
December 29, 2025
"Good ingredients, good results"
I’ve picked up a few skincare products from Beauty Pie now, and the main thing I notice is how solid the ingredient lists are. I’m seeing a lot of the same kind of ingredients I’ve found in much more expensive creams, but the products don’t have that heavy, filler-like feel on my skin. So far my skin seems calmer and happier, and I haven’t had any breakouts from anything I’ve tried. Based on how my skin has reacted, I’d say the quality is genuinely really decent...
SalvadorBusby
December 13, 2025
"Wish I’d Trusted My Gut"
I regret going through with this. Something about the whole experience felt a bit shady, like they weren’t being completely upfront with me. I kept hoping it would turn out fine, but looking back, I wish I had listened to that uneasy feeling sooner.
verafrazier5393
December 01, 2025
"I really like that Beauty Pie…"
I really like that Beauty Pie shows both the member price and the regular price, so it’s easier to see what I’m actually saving. You still have to do a little mental math on some items once you factor in the membership cost, but overall the pricing feels way more upfront than a lot of beauty sites. Solid 4 stars from me!

View More Reviews

Have a question about Beauty Pie?
beautypie

Beauty Pie Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.